Sunday, April 25, 2010

Consumer Marketing Techniques and Tribes

Most of us like to think that we're too sophisticated to fall for marketing tricks. We know that "new" and "improved" don't necessarily mean a product is really new or improved. We know that larger boxes and bottles of some products are usually, but not always, less expensive per ounce than smaller sizes. We know that added bells and whistles don't always mean better quality items. But the reality is that marketing pros are consistently at least one step ahead of us when it comes to manipulating our buying habits.

I've mentioned in a previous post the book Predictably Irrational: The Hidden Forces That Shape Our Decisions by Dan Ariely, but I'd like to take a closer look at a few specific observations that he discussed and offer my own assessment of what ultimately motivates us to make purchasing decisions.  Also, FYI, a "revised and expanded edition" of Predictably Irrational will be released on April 27th; I assume it really is revised and expanded!

(Thanks to the blogs "Coding Horror" and "SEOmozBlog" for providing the quotes that form the basis of the first three items.)

Relative Thinking and "Saving Money"

"When Williams-Sonoma introduced bread machines, sales were slow. When they added a 'deluxe' version that was 50% more expensive, they started flying off the shelves; the first bread machine now appeared to be a bargain."


"When contemplating the purchase of a $25 pen, the majority of subjects would drive to another store 15 minutes away to save $7. When contemplating the purchase of a $455 suit, the majority of subjects would not drive to another store 15 minutes away to save $7. The amount saved and time involved are the same, but people make very different choices."

Clearly, we like to believe we're rational when it comes to saving money on purchases, but we're not. We often fall down on the job of accurate comparison shopping. A related trap, this one self-imposed rather than inflicted by clever marketing, is spending an inordinate amount of time shopping for an item at a lower price. Driving across town to save less money than we'll spend on gas is counter-productive; so is driving across town if our time is more valuable than the money we'll save by shopping somewhere inconvenient.

Artificial Markets

"Savador Assael, the Pearl King, single-handedly created the market for black pearls, which were unknown in the industry before 1973. His first attempt to market the pearls was an utter failure; he didn't sell a single pearl. So he went to his friend, Harry Winston, and had Winston put them in the window of his 5th Avenue store with an outrageous price tag attached. Then he ran full page ads in glossy magazines with black pearls next to diamonds, rubies, and emeralds. Soon, black pearls were considered precious."


The creation of an artificial market is not exclusive to luxury items. For example, gadgets of all sorts have been invented ostensibly to make our lives easier, but many are totally unnecessary. Responding to the instant appeal of ultimately useless gadgets can drain your bank account and fill your home with clutter. (See the Unclutterer blog's amusing "Unitasker Wednesday" items for examples of these gadgets.)

Price and Perception of Value

"Ariely, Waber, Shiv, and Carmon made up a fake painkiller, Veladone-Rx. An attractive woman in a business suit (with a faint Russian accent) told subjects that 92% of patients receiving VR reported significant pain relief in 10 minutes, with relief lasting up to 8 hours.


"When told that the drug cost $2.50 per dose, nearly all of the subjects reported pain relief. When told that the drug cost $0.10 per dose, only half of the subjects reported pain relief. The more pain a person experienced, the more pronounced the effect. A similar study at U Iowa showed that students who paid list price for cold medications reported better medical outcomes than those who bought discount (but clinically identical) drugs."

Although we say we want value, we often are suspicious when it's offered to us. This is why many brand names have greater appeal than their generic equivalents. Of course, anyone who's tried a generic product (not a drug with a specific active ingredient, but simply a "store brand" item) and found it to be genuinely inferior will be justifiably cautious in future money-saving purchases. On the other hand, at what point does an expensive car, for example, become worth its price? If a car were simply transportation, there would be no reason to pay a premium. But a car is an aesthetic statement as well as a public proclamation of status. Once status becomes an issue, all bets are off and the marketing mavens have a field day.
 
Buying the Image, Not the Item
 
Let's face it. The real reason that we buy anything beyond basic food staples that keep us alive is that we are making a statement about who we are or who we aspire to be. Not only are human beings visual creatures who respond primarily to appearances, but we are also social creatures who are constantly tuned into the hierarchies of status around us. We choose (or struggle to choose) an image that works for us and the "tribes" we want to affiliate with, then we gather the associated trappings. If you shop at Victoria's Secret and I shop at LL Bean, that says something about each of us and the tribes we identify with. If you drive a Mercedes and I drive a Honda, that speaks volumes, too. If you say that diamonds are a girl's best friend and I say that a girl's best friend is her dog, marketing pros are going to know exactly how to push each of our buttons to get us to reinforce our personal visions and our tribal affiliations.
 
Every label you put on yourself, or that society imposes upon you, puts you in a tribe:
young/old/mom/dad/dancer/writer/accountant/athlete/conservative/liberal/city dweller/nature lover/quiet/outgoing, etc. The labels you identify with most strongly are your most significant tribes and are usually most visible in your personal style and your lifestyle. We like to think that we're individualistic in our choices, especially in this society where individuality is such an admired characteristic, but I think that's rarely the case. I believe that the tribal connections are generally more powerful than our individual inclinations. Few of us are as bold as Lynn Yaeger when it comes to personal style and perhaps even in her case an argument can be made that embracing an exceptionally unorthodox look puts her in a tribe of "rebels" or "iconoclasts." 
 
Whatever our personal styles and tribal affiliations may be, if we become truly aware of them, of who we think we are and what statement we want to project to the world, we can make decisions that are comfortable for us. Or we can reject our status quo and reinvent ourselves. Either way, we can start taking charge of all that clever marketing information and use it to our advantage instead of being manipulated by it.
 
Who are you? What are your tribes? How does what you buy reinforce your image of yourself and what you project to the world? Can you spot instances in which you were manipulated? Do you feel empowered to make satisfying choices in the future?
 
 
© 2010 Cynthia Friedlob
Photo credit: Avalore @ stock.xchng

Related posts:
Advertising's Assault on Our Senses
Style, Advertising and the Cool Factor
Advertising to Children in a Consumer Society

Sunday, March 28, 2010

More Motivation for Uncluttering

A few links and a few thoughts to help keep you motivated:

Spring cleaning doesn't do much good if you haven't done spring uncluttering first. That's what Wall Street Journal columnist Sue Shellenbarger learned when she personally tackled "Ditching 800 Pounds of Clutter."  Her six-week experiment to clean out and clean up turned out well in spite of some frustrations during the process. There are a couple of good before and after pix to see at this link, too. (Thanks to Unclutterer.com for pointing out this WSJ article that was published last week.)

"The Story of Stuff: Cycle of Consuming and Dumping Creates Heavy Baggage," by DeNeen L. Brown in Saturday's Washington Post, was prompted by Annie Leonard's new book, The Story of Stuff. Yes, Ms. Leonard is the same person who made the engrossing twenty minute video of the same title that many of you probably have already seen. The WaPo article talks about not only the crisis created by our cultural obsession with consumerism, but also the emotional connection we have with our stuff. An aside: I was amused that Ms. Brown referred to how we used to be able to fit all we owned in a Honda Civic; my generation remembers and probably fantasizes about how we used to be able to fit all we owned in a Volkswagen. The vehicles change, but the sentiment remains -- although there's more room in a Civic! (Thanks to friend and former neighbor, Rachel, for the article link.)

Ultimately, our relationship with most of our stuff is pretty indefensible for one simple reason: you can't take it with you. I've been hanging onto the link to this LA Times article for quite awhile: "Selling What the Dead Leave Behind". Okay, it's not a cheery topic, but it's worth thinking about. You may have heirs that will deal with all your possessions (whether they want to or not is another issue), but what happens if no one is around to sort out your stuff after you've shuffled off this mortal coil? In Los Angeles, the county auctions your belongings to the public. This article provides an informative and poignant look at the process. It's a good reality check for all of us.

We're mid-Discardia right now; it continues until April 14th. I mentioned in my previous post that I'm using this "holiday" to help motivate me to unclutter what may be the final layer in my own archaeological dig through stuff that now seems superfluous to me. I also mentioned that I needed to figure out when my sense of obligation to unclutter was legitimate, not just something I felt I "should" do. What I'm discovering is that I don't have as much left to let go as I thought. I'm not exactly streamlined, but I don't feel the nagging sense of being burdened that I used to have several years ago. If "The Big One" hit LA and we were shaken and rattled out of our home, never to return (Heaven forbid, of course!), there are only a few things I'd miss. Photographs and some handmade mementos are all that I'd be truly sorry to lose. I can't do much about the mementos, other than continue to enjoy having them for as long as the ground remains steady, but I can do something about the photographs by posting them in online albums. That will be a good use of some of my time.

Of course, I'll continue to sort and toss whatever things are left that need to go, but I'll do it gradually. The most significant clutter I'm going to part with immediately is that sense of obligation to be "done." I think letting go of that will allow me to move forward with some current projects that I've been putting on hold until the magic state of "done" had been achieved. I regret to confess that this desire to be done is an excellent example of perfectionism getting in the way of living. To quote Discardia creator, Dinah Sanders (italics are mine):

Discardia is celebrated by getting rid of stuff and ideas you no longer need. It's about letting go, abdicating from obligation and guilt, being true to the self you are now. Discardia is the time to get rid of things that no longer add value to your life, shed bad habits, let go of emotional baggage and generally lighten your load.

Turns out that my useless mental baggage is more bother than my remaining tangible stuff! It's time to let it go, too, and adopt Dinah's motto in my home, my head and my life:

Make room for awesomeness.


© 2010 Cynthia Friedlob
Photo credit: asifthebes at stock.xchng

Monday, March 15, 2010

Spring Cleaning and a Free Book

Spring is a sign of renewal so it's not surprising that we cling to the concept of spring cleaning, even though the messy coal-burning stoves that prompted the ritual are long gone from our homes. If you live in a climate where you have winter, those first days of warm sunshine still make you want to celebrate the season in a clean home. Those of us here in sunny SoCal don't experience a dramatic change of weather at this time of year, but I must have some kind of spring fever anyway because cleaning up is exactly what I want to do. My problem is what I call "The Final Layer of Clutter" and it's in my way; at least, it's in the way in my head.

I've spent the last several years sorting, tossing, donating and generally unburdening myself of a lot of possessions. And burdensome is exactly how they felt, even though some of those possessions were beautiful antiques I had inherited and had enjoyed living with, familiar things I grew up with that brought me fond memories, and lovely newer things I had acquired with great enthusiasm at the time of purchase. I don't know what flipped the switch in my head, but suddenly I wanted to feel liberated in a way that I couldn't if I was responsible for all that stuff.

The notion of responsibility for our possessions isn't hard to understand; we worked hard, and our families worked hard in the past, in order to have all the comforts and luxuries we enjoy. It doesn't take much introspection to generate feelings of gratitude for having these things and the sense of obligation to care for the stuff properly kicks in quickly, too. If we inherited things, whether valuable or not, that puts an extra layer of responsibility on us. But the notion of being the caretaker of the family history in the form of ownership of stuff can be perceived as a welcome privilege or an oppressive weight, or anything in between.

Because I don't have children who would inherit the family furniture, dishes, etc. (and, believe me, not every child is thrilled to inherit every item we each deem important), I had to make a decision about what to do with most of my sentimental stuff. Yes, I did keep some things that are particularly significant to me and that still bring me joy; for the rest, I opted for what I called my "pre-estate sale." This allowed me to be the one to make choices about where I wanted things to go. That did not necessarily make it easy to let go of these items because, even though I was well aware of how much I wanted to feel that sense of freedom, I didn't simply turn into an unsentimental person. Even now, I can still get a little twinge at times when I think of all that I parted with, but, fortunately, a moment of reflection puts me back in touch with the certain knowledge that I did the right thing.

However, The Final Layer of Clutter is not only a small amount of remaining sentimental stuff. In fact, much of it doesn't have any sentiment attached to it at all. But it does have that sense of obligation hanging over it: I know I should do something with it. Often the sense of obligation is totally misplaced, so I need to make sure I really do need to do something with these things and, if I do, I need to act on it. Do I need or truly want to organize and scan my family photographs? Yes. Do I need or truly want to keep a stash of old costume jewelry? No.

I think I had battle fatigue after letting go of so much truly important stuff and then making sure I reached my goal in last year's 365 Item Toss Challenge (I exceeded it!). And now I face The Final Layer. My solution? I'm preparing to celebrate one of my favorite holidays again: Discardia. I first heard of Discardia from blogger Jeri Dansky on her popular blog, Jeri's Organizing and Decluttering News and I've posted about it in the past (here and here). The short explanation of the holiday, according to its founder, Dina Sanders, is that Discardia is about "letting go of stuff and ideas that you don't need." It's celebrated between the Solstices & Equinoxes and their following new moons. The next Discardia begins on Saturday, March 20th, and ends on April 14th. Even though Discardia is strictly a no-pressure holiday, I'm going to use it to motivate me to do my best to deal with The Final Layer of Clutter during that time. I'm also going to make a major effort to unload some of the useless mental baggage that I cart around.

To help motivate you, I'm going to give away a copy of my book, Sorting It Out: One Disorganized Woman Solves the Problem of Too Much Stuff. All you have to do is leave a comment telling me what kind of spring cleaning and uncluttering you plan to do. Are you at the beginning of your uncluttering efforts or have you made lots of progress? Do you have sentimental stuff that's holding you back or are you simply swamped by everything? Do you already have your house in order and live the life of a thoughtful consumer? Whoever you are, please join the discussion. I'll use a random number generator to choose the winner (assuming more than one faithful reader responds!) and I'll announce the name in the comments of this post next Saturday, the 20th, day one of the spring Discardia celebration.

Let's see if we can make spring cleaning fun! Okay, that's probably too much to ask. Let's just make this a fun contest!

© 2010 Cynthia Friedlob
Photo by littlekata at stock.xchng

Thursday, March 11, 2010

FBI Scams and Social Network Schemes

The FBI offers continually updated alerts online about consumer scams and I encourage you to read the entire current list for details. You can even sign up for e-mails if you'd like to be notified immediately about the latest trickery afoot. Undoubtedly, the Nigerian prince who desperately needs your assistance to claim his inheritance is still prowling around, but there are always other nefarious characters brewing up new schemes. Below is some general information about just a few favorite scams that target all of us.

Bogus Charities: It's hard to believe that a tragedy like the earthquake in Haiti would bring out scammers, but it did, just as other tragedies have in the past. Fraudulent charities with familiar-sounding names solicit help via e-mail, a much more efficient system than in the old days when they had to rely on phone calls or snail mail. You'd think that anyone receiving a solicitation would check to make sure the charity was legit, but apparently that's not the case. This is still a profitable scam that harvests credit card information and sometimes cash and check payments. Solution: Verify the legitimacy of any charity before you make a donation. Charity Navigator can help you do this; the site also provides rankings of charities that show you how efficiently donations are being used.

Scareware: Have you ever seen an abrupt and usually noisy pop-up while you're online, warning that your computer is "infected with a virus?" That's scareware and it's a scam to get you to buy fake software. Download the advertised "virus protection" program and you could end up installing viruses, Trojans or keyloggers instead. (Keyloggers are particularly insidious; they allow the scammer access to your passwords.) The FBI estimates a loss of over $150 million to victims of this kind of scam. Solution: Make sure you have real virus protection software installed on your computer. If you do encounter one of these pop-up notices, just close your browser and run a virus scan in case there are any problems resulting from the pop-up.

Economic Stimulus Checks: Some clever scammers have sent e-mails purportedly from the IRS, stating that the recipient is eligible for an economic stimulus check from the government. Considering the sorry state of the economy and the lure of getting a piece of the well-pulicized but apparently little-understood stimulus package, this could easily hook an unsuspecting consumer. Of course, the recipient has to provide all kinds of personal information, including bank account numbers, before the "stimulus check" can be issued. Solution: Never give any personal information in response to an unsolicited e-mail; the government and financial institutions never send requests for such sensitive information via e-mail.

Numerous other scams are circulating online right now, including fake work as a "mystery shopper" (there are some legitimate mystery shopping sites, but you must find out which ones they are); fake greeting card links that install a virus if you click on them (cards sent from legitimate sites always identify the name of the friend who sent the card); work at home scams that involve "processing payments," "transferring funds" or "re-shipping items;" numerous scams trying to get personal financial information by using the names of government officials in the e-mails in order to look official; even a scam in which the e-mail recipient is told s/he has been selected to appear on Oprah Winfrey's "Millionaire Show" and all s/he has to do is buy a plane ticket, a show ticket and provide some personal information. Solution: Verify, verify, verify and remember the old adage that if something seems too good to be true, it probably is.

Social networking can be great fun but it also has created a friendly new system for scammers to exploit. Here's a quote from the FBI's update page (italics are mine):

Fraudsters continue to hijack accounts on social networking sites and spread malicious software by using various techniques. One technique involves the use of spam to promote phishing sites [phishing: trying to get sensitive information illegally], claiming there has been a violation of the terms of agreement or some other type of issue which needs to be resolved. Other spam entices users to download an application or view a video. Some spam appears to be sent from users' "friends," giving the perception of being legitimate. Once the user responds to the phishing site, downloads the application, or clicks on the video link, their computer, telephone or other digital device becomes infected.

Another technique used by fraudsters involves applications advertised on social networking sites, which appear legitimate; however, some of these applications install malicious code or rogue anti-virus software. Other malicious software gives the fraudsters access to your profile and personal information. These programs will automatically send messages to your "friends" list, instructing them to download the new application, too [further contaminating the pool of the social network's users].

I enjoy using Facebook to keep up with friends, many long-lost, and to share links to stories or websites I find interesting. But I've avoided all of the Facebook applications, even the "legitimate" ones, because they allow the application to access to my friends' information. I'm a fairly public user of the site because I also use it to promote my blog and website which, in turn, promote my book and art that are for sale. However, I still don't want my information provided to any applications and I certainly don't want my friends' information provided to them, even if the applications seem to be sending only harmless little "gifts." One Facebook user I'm aware of has had his identity hijacked and his entire list of friends was spammed yesterday with several bogus messages -- an annoying and potentially embarrassing situation. Solution: Think twice before automatically clicking on an advertising link on your social network page or on a video supposedly sent by a friend. And remember that there's no such thing as a free iMac!

[An aside: Of course, Facebook and other social networking sites aren't the only possible sources of annoying and embarrassing spam attacks on one's friends. I've had my e-mail names cloned on both services that I use and a couple that I don't. Apparently "I" haven't spammed my list (I'm certain someone would have informed me), but I do occasionally receive spam at my own addresses from "myself!"]

There's certainly nothing new about people using trickery to steal from other people, but the Internet opens up opportunities of unprecedented scale. A dedicated online scammer can target many thousands of marks in the time it used to take a snail-mail fraudster to address an envelope. Solution: Be very thoughtful before you click.

© 2010 Cynthia Friedlob
Photo credit: sqback on stock.xchng

Thursday, February 11, 2010

Transportation and the Irrational Consumer

I learned two disappointing facts of life when I grew up: (1) people are not logical and (2) making good choices is often not as simple as it first appears to be, even when we know "the facts."

Our lack of logic doesn't mean that we make random choices; we use what logical abilities we have, but we're sub-consciously influenced and can be manipulated by all sorts of factors like emotions, expectations and social norms. And, probably because we're mostly "pack animals" of sorts and have similar hard-wiring in our brains, we seem to make the same kinds of errors in logic repeatedly and collectively. The currently popular book, Predictably Irrational: The Hidden Forces That Shape Our Decisions, by MIT professor Dan Ariely, delves into this issue (quote from Amazon.com):


Not only do we make astonishingly simple mistakes every day, but we make the same types of mistakes, Ariely discovers. We consistently overpay, underestimate, and procrastinate. We fail to understand the profound effects of our emotions on what we want, and we overvalue what we already own. Yet these misguided behaviors are neither random nor senseless. They're systematic and predictable—making us predictably irrational.

Other contemporary authors come to similar conclusions about our inability to be as logical as we like to think we are: Sway: The Irresistible Pull of Irrational Behavior, by Ori Brafman and Rom Brafman; A Mind of Its Own: How Your Brain Distorts and Deceives, by Cordelia Fine; Blink: The Power of Thinking Without Thinking, by Malcolm Gladwell, who has a cottage industry in books about human behavior and how the mind works. But the general concept is nothing new; the flaws in human logic were well-observed by Charles Mackay in one of my favorite books, Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds, published in 1841. In fact, I wouldn't be surprised to learn that there's some sort of documentation about us being illogical that dates to the cave drawings in Lascaux.

In spite of this, we all make myriad decisions daily using our apparently limited skills, and we do the best that we can. But surely the decision-making process must be complicated further when we discover there are multiple choices and when we're informed that compelling arguments for more than one choice can be made. It certainly seems complicated to me.

In previous posts (see below for links), I've discussed some of the challenges we face when we're trying to make environmentally-responsible decisions. Everything from the value of using ethanol fuel to that of re-using cloth grocery bags can be debated, sometimes with impressive research backing both sides of an argument. But my own completely non-scientific, observational research indicates that the most significant factor influencing our decision-making is the "cool factor." Facts and logic take a backseat to cool more often than we'd like to admit. Of course, we're influenced in our choices about what's cool, too, but let's save analyzing that phenomenon for posts about the power of advertising. For now, let's look instead at an example of a surprisingly debatable issue: something as "simple" and "straightforward" as the advantage of public vs. private transportation.

Most of use would say that efficient, high-speed rail that moves many people would be a better choice than everyone owning cars. But Suzanne Smalley of Newsweek.com reported that "many economists now say the costs of building a high-speed rail network far outstrip the possible benefits, especially when cars are becoming more energy-efficient." Of course, this conclusion doesn't take into account the problems Toyota is having right now with the fuel-efficient Camry, the most popular car in America, or the problems with the Prius, the most popular hybrid car in the country, but we can safely assume that those problems will be resolved eventually.

Will this pro-car point of view have a significant impact on the car-buying choices and public transportation plans we make in the future? Will trends away from ostentatious, gas-guzzling vehicles continue because of the economy? Perceived and, perhaps, actual advantages to public transportation resulted in President Obama allocating $8 billion for high-speed trains in the stimulus package, and Congress upping the figure by another $1.2 billion. Does that mean that the previously agreed upon logic of the value of public transportation has won the battle? Or will we ultimately be affected by the "cool factor" more than anything else?

I vote for the "cool factor." The economy may dictate certain changes but, if there's any wiggle-room at all in our budgets, we're most persuaded by what kind of statement our purchases make. It's currently cool and getting cooler to own fuel-efficient cars. Hybrid and alternative choices are still optional. But there's nothing cool about daily public transportation, unless perhaps it's a bullet train or, for short trips, a cute trolley or double-deck bus. Otherwise, public transportation is perceived only as functional, to a greater or lesser degree. Until public transportation becomes fashionable, any debate based on the "logic" of its environmental advantage or lack of advantage won't be as significant as it should be, considering the impact the ultimate choice will have.

Of course, the other big issue about public vs. private transportation is convenience. In Los Angeles, it's pretty much impossible to rely exclusively on public transportation even if you want to. (You can read more than you probably need to know about this in the NY Times Freakonomics series about transporation in LA; the comments are integral to understanding what's really going on in this city and are often more accurate than the articles.) Los Angeles can claim the number one worst commute in the country (the Hollywood Freeway headed into downtown LA always, I repeat, always slows down at Vermont Ave.) and residents complain endlessly about traffic, but giving up a car would mean giving up reasonable access to the vast majority of the urban area. In addition, because this is a car town, cars are (too) often used as a reflection of the owner's status and personality.

So, give up your car and in return get inconvenience and a loss of identity? That's definitely not cool.

Would you give up your car? Does your city or town have adequate public transportation?

© 2010 Cynthia Friedlob
Photo by Cieleke at stock.xchng


Related posts:
Going Wrong, Going Green
Going Wrong, Going Green, Part 2

Friday, January 22, 2010

Counterfeits and Consumers


Consumers already have enough trouble trying to make responsible choices without adding the burden of worrying about avoiding counterfeit goods. Unfortunately, thanks to fact that people are flawed creatures, counterfeit products often invade the marketplace because their manufacturers hope to make a quick buck. While this is certainly unfair to legitimate manufacturers and trusting consumers of such commonly counterfeited things as handbags or watches, it can be deadly if the counterfeit product is a condom.

Of course, it's highly unlikely that anyone would choose to purchase fake condoms (we know that some less-discriminating people do make that choice for handbags and watches), but what happens if the packaging is good enough to fool an unsuspecting consumer into buying the fakes? That consumer runs the risk of contracting or spreading sexually-transmitted diseases, including HIV.

When I saw the article, "China's Latest Scandal is Counterfeit Condoms," on today's LA Times website, I thought I'd investigate further. What I discovered is that the condom scandal is nothing new. The press has been talking about it for years. Here's a timeline of reporting about the issue, using just a sample of articles from various sources:

2005 March 17 - The BBC News reported that thousands of fake condoms had hit the market in the UK.

2006 December 4 - The Guardian published an article about counterfeit drugs that included this reference to counterfeit condoms:
A few years ago, Durex executives were astonished to discover pirated condoms bearing their brand name on the production line of a prospective Chinese partner's factory. "It sparked a discussion among the visitors about whether they had found the perfect supplier," said Calum MacLeod, a consultant to Durex at the time. "But from a corporate ethics point of view, it was not realistic."
2007 December 19 - ConsumerAffairs.com cited condoms as one of many products on a list of high risk drug and medical items. The article also stated:
[Secretary of Health and Human Services Michael] Leavitt signed two agreements with the Chinese government last week that puts the onus on the Chinese and their manufacturers rather than the beleaguered inspectors of the dozen U.S. agencies responsible for imported goods. . . Despite the strong language of the accords and the report, Leavitt did not hail it as a victory or even a long-term cure. . . The Chinese grudgingly agreed to these accords in the face of a more than year-long public relations disaster and it may be difficult getting them to follow through because most reports out of the country reveal that agency leaders don't actually believe there is a serious problem.
2008 June 3 - Tu Salud, The Latino Wellness Magazine, reported about the discovery of sales of millions of fake Chinese condoms in discount stores in New York. (They referenced a May 5th Newsday story that's no longer available online.)

2009 November 11 - UPI.com posted a story about a factory in Hunan Province that had manufactured more than two million counterfeit condoms in the previous eight months:
Four people were arrested at the factory which was distributing illicit condoms nationwide that provided little or no protection and carried the risk of both pregnancy and disease. . . Authorities say when they entered the factory they saw bare-chested employees using vegetable oil to lubricate the condoms and putting them into fiber bags without any sterilization.
2010 January 21 - The LA Times article I mentioned earlier references incidents dating back to 2008 and concludes with a comment about how the Chinese government has handled counterfeiting (italics are mine):
"Given the vast size and complexities of the society, it is not surprising that there continue to be problems with product quality," said Zha Daojiong, a professor at Peking University's School of International Studies. "Back in the early 1990s, the Chinese government repeatedly launched 'strike hard' campaigns -- throwing those involved in producing and selling below-quality products to years in jail.". . But, he added, proper monitoring systems cost money, resulting in higher prices. . ."It's impossible to have enhanced surveillance on the cheap," Zha said. "A genuine dialogue [needs] to take place between the government and the populace at large [about] the costs the average consumer is prepared to pay."
The Chinese government has been trying to stop the manufacture of these counterfeit products since at least the early 1900s according to this article, but I have no doubt that it's been an issue much longer than that. I also think it's safe to assume that there are plenty of credible articles in the press about Chinese counterfeit items that pre-date the few I've listed from the last five years. We've been adequately informed. But the significant issue now is that increased trade with China has resulted in the importing of many more types of items in much greater quantities than ever before. And if the general perception in China is that counterfeiting is not a significant problem, then the risks associated with buying certain Chinese products are substantial.

How do we cope with these kinds of threats? Making sure that we're aware of them through the work of a vigilant press is the first crucial step. Obviously, there are certain governmental restrictions that can be imposed on imports. More extensive and thorough safety inspections of imports can help, too. We live in a global economy, so we can't always buy American-made goods; also, some goods labelled as made in this country use parts or materials imported from other countries. And there's always the possibility that counterfeit products can be made right here, too. It's enough to kick a person's paranoia up a notch or two.

But I also think that the Chinese professor's observation in the LA Times article touches on part of the problem: are consumers always going to choose the least expensive option or will we be willing to pay more in order to get better (in this case, safer) products?

Lots of us are watching our spending more closely now because of the economic crisis that has affected the majority of our population. That means shopping for "bargains." But cheap isn't always a bargain. As a society, we need to make an important shift in our thinking and realize that buying fewer things of higher quality from trusted manufacturers (or, in the case of some products, from local sources) is better than buying lots of things of shoddy, or perhaps even unsafe, quality.

Consumer decisions are often more complicated than they seem on the surface, but there's nothing to debate when it comes to avoiding dangerous counterfeit products. We can't control all of the factors that allow them to get to market, but to be safe, we can and must make reasonably informed decisions when we're shopping for food, drugs and other medical items.

So, let's kick that paranoia back down where it belongs and remember that thoughtful consumers just do the best we can to avoid fakes. Like the song says, "Ain't nothin' like the real thing."

© 2010 Cynthia Friedlob
Photo credit: seesky @ stock.XCHNG

Sunday, January 17, 2010

Connections: Cadmium-Tainted Children's Jewelry and Why We Should Still Buy Newspapers



China is a country intent on growth from increasing exports but, whether through ignorance, carelessness or greed, it has a history of selling contaminated products, such as toothpaste, cough syrup and melamine-tainted milk. When they arrive in the U.S., all of those products fall under the jurisdiction of the Food and Drug Administration, the federal agency charged with the daunting task of regulating and ensuring the safety of food, drugs and many other products that affect our health.

Many other consumer products, including toys and jewelry, are the concern of the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, another agency with a gigantic task involving the protection of the American public. Because of China's woeful record with deadly exported food, it should come as no great surprise that companies in China have been selling dangerous cadmium-laden inexpensive children's jewelry and trinkets to the U.S. Recent studies indicate that cadmium may be more toxic than lead to the developing brains of very young children. It was rather astonishing that the public response from at least one Chinese jewelry seller just a day after the Associated Press broke this story was that using cadmium cuts costs and profit was the only concern for the makers (see this article):

"Business is business, and it's all up to our client," said He Huihua, manager of the Suiyuan Jewelry Shop at International Trade City in Yiwu, a sprawling wholesale mecca where sellers pitch their wares in hopes of landing a lucrative export contract."

The response by U.S. retailers was swift. Wal-Mart pulled the jewelry immediately and other retailers followed suit. I would imagine that Wal-Mart, so often the big corporate "bad guy" in consumer stories, enjoyed having an opportunity to take an indisputably correct stance:

"Melissa Hill, a spokeswoman for Wal-Mart Stores Inc., called the AP findings 'troubling.' She said the company, which is the world's largest retailer, had a special responsibility 'to take swift action, and we are doing so.'"

AP writers Justin Pritchard and Jeff Donn also reported:

"U.S.-based trade groups, as well as distributors and sellers of the jewelry containing cadmium, said their products meet safety standards. Cadmium is regulated in painted toys but not in jewelry. . . 'This is just the latest example of the need for stronger consumer safety laws in this country, especially for products manufactured and marketed for children, and shows yet again why products from China should be subject to additional scrutiny,' said Rep. Rosa L. DeLauro, a Connecticut Democrat."

What an interesting, complex story that involves government agencies, corporations, and most significantly and wonderfully, at least to me, the press:

1. Cadmium, a hazardous metal, is not federally regulated when used in jewelry, information reported in the press when this story broke, resulting in many calls for such regulation.

2. Children's jewelry that was saturated with the metal (sometimes as much as 90% of its content) was manufactured in China because using the metal was cheap, as the press discovered through their own AP-funded investigation and research.

3.
The press reported that the jewelry was being exported to major U.S. retailers whose primary appeal to the public is offering inexpensive goods.

4. The retailers stopped selling the jewelry, we hope for wholly for ethical and responsible reasons, but also certainly to avoid a public relations nightmare in the press.

5. Consumers are being alerted by the press so that they can get rid of the tainted jewelry before their children are harmed.

Internet lovers (and, obviously, I like being online, too), please take note that it was the Associated Press that broke this story. The AP, a mainstream media giant, was founded in 1846. Here's its mission statement (italics are mine):

"AP's mission is to be the essential global news network, providing distinctive news services of the highest quality, reliability and objectivity with reports that are accurate, balanced and informed. AP operates as a not-for-profit cooperative with more than 4,000 employees working in more than 240 worldwide bureaus. AP is owned by its 1,500 U.S. daily newspaper members. They elect a board of directors that directs the cooperative."

Those daily newspapers are suffering right now, cutting back reporters and columnists, and struggling to provide a crucial service to all of us.

Even the most noble government servants must deal with bureaucracies and political agendas, and even the most benevolent corporations are beholden to stockholders and profit motives, but a truly free press is the thoughtful consumer's best friend.

The LA Times. The New York Times. The Washington Post.

Your paper?

© 2010 Cynthia Friedlob
Photo credit: Lusi at Stock.XCHNG

Tuesday, January 12, 2010

City Living: Designed for Thoughtful Consumers?



Being a thoughtful consumer doesn't just mean making wise personal decisions about purchasing, recycling and donating; it also means contributing to making larger decisions about where and how you live and work. Wherever that may be, the built environment that houses and surrounds you is planned, efficiently or not so efficiently, and that affects you as a consumer and a citizen.

There's ample evidence that the practice of designing cities, what we call "urban planning," has been around for thousands of years. Once a sizable population gathered in one relatively small area, streets or paths were laid out in a grid pattern, drainage and other water use systems were set up, and sometimes walls were constructed for protection, all for the purpose of making city life work. Modern cities face a similar challenge to those of their predecessors: how should a city be built to provide the best possible environment for its inhabitants? There are issues of safety and functionality to be considered, but aesthetics are important, too. Jails are urban microcosms, but most of us wouldn't be happy to live in those surroundings, even if we weren't forcibly detained inside them.

Throughout the U.S., cities were the vibrant centers of community life for generations. But after decades of unprecedented rapid increases in both population and construction, eventually crowding and deterioration afflicted many urban areas. The process of "urban renewal" in the last century was a sporadically successful effort to reclaim some of the positive aspects of city life that had been lost.

The real blow to the perceived desirability of city living in the U.S. was the return of GIs after WW II and the development of the suburbs. The American Dream became defined by a single family home with a yard and, significantly, a car. Living outside of the city was made possible by the ability to commute. Cars and the highways created to accommodate them were the factors that most altered urban landscapes.

But now, years after many of our cities sprawled for miles, their centers collapsed and turned nightmarish, a renaissance of urban life has been occurring across the country. Is life at the center of the city "The Next American Dream?" That's the thesis of the interesting documentary of that title from filmmakers who examined the re-birth of Kansas City, Missouri, over the last several years. (See the brief trailer here.) I saw the show on a PBS station in the LA area recently, but you can check your local stations for broadcasts scheduled later this month.

While "The Next American Dream" examines the societal changes that are making cities more appealing again, an episode of the PBS series LIFE (Part 2) examines what sort of communities allow people to flourish and live longer-than-average life spans. (YouTube clip here.) Turns out that one of the important factors is living in a walkable community, something that's provided by an urban rather than rural environment. Reduction in obesity is cited as one of the benefits, but I would think that there are also advantageous social aspects. Part of the "French Paradox" may have to do with drinking red wine, but living in a walkable community and spending much time socializing at the local cafe probably help, too.

How would your life as a consumer change if you lived and worked in a well-designed city? Walking more and being able to rely on public transportation would mean better personal health, less consumption of fuel, even less need for owning a car. You'd eliminate the stress of a long commute. You'd probably be more inclined to patronize local businesses. Access to cultural events would be easier. You'd live in a smaller space and probably would own less useful stuff as well as less clutter. You'd share outdoor spaces like parks and plazas rather than maintaining your own yard. There might be community gardens, too. There would be potential for a very nice balance of private and public spaces. Much urban planning today also includes "sustainable development" that considers environmental impact while working simultaneously to achieve a workable, comfortable city life. What's good for you can also be good (well, at least not so bad) for the planet.

There are some excellent resources to peruse if you'd like to learn and think more about city life. I was pleased to discover that William H. Whyte's terrific book City: Rediscovering the Center was reissued in paperback last August. He also wrote The Social Life of Small Urban Spaces, a brilliantly insightful book (there's also an accompanying film) that was the result of his Street Life Project, "a pioneering study of pedestrian behavior and city dynamics."

Planetizen is a fascinating website that "prides itself on covering a wide number of planning, design, and development issues, from transportation to global warming, architecture to infrastructure, housing and community development to historic preservation. We provide a forum for people across the political and ideological spectrum, ensuring a healthy debate on these and other important issues." For an example, check out this post, "In Praise of Mid-Century Modern Planning," which links to an article in New Geography, calling for design diversity.

We all can have an impact on our built environments, whether we're in a big city or a small town, by informing ourselves about the decisions that affect the structure and infrastructure of our entire communities and acting to make sure that those decisions are responsible. To do this, we need to refocus our thinking, at least at times, to consider what it means to be consumers on a much bigger scale.

In the 1970s, many people thought that the answer to society's problems could be found by going "back to the land." Today, maybe the answer is going back to the cities.

© 2010 Cynthia Friedlob
Artwork: © 2009 Mandie LeScum, stock.xchng

Wednesday, December 30, 2009

New Day Resolutions

Bill Vaughn, the late Kansas City Star columnist and author, once observed about New Year's Eve that "an optimist stays up until midnight to see the New Year; a pessimist stays up to make sure the old one leaves." I suspect that most of us combine both of those outlooks, eager to put any unpleasant memories behind us and hopeful that the coming year will provide many happy ones.

I also have mixed feelings about the annual ritual of making resolutions. Sometimes those vows to ourselves can be motivating, but sometimes they set us up for feelings of failure. Part of the problem is the intense focus on making dramatic changes starting on one particular day, January 1st, as if no other day were suitable for such tasks and as if small changes were not important. Fall off the resolution wagon, as so many of us do, and the whole year is shot. Of course, that's not true, but we often feel that way.

So, this year I've decided to abandon New Year's resolutions in favor of the approach that British sculptor Henry Moore advocated: "I think in terms of the day's resolutions, not the year's." I much prefer this option to reinvent myself on a smaller scale every day rather than in some major form once a year. Thinking in terms of daily reinventions will allow me to avoid the usual large, annual goal-oriented resolutions -- even such worthy ones as last year's plan to lose mffwhty pounds (unsuccessful) or the 365 Item Toss Unclutterer Challenge (successful!).

But resolutions, no matter what their scale or how often they're promised, require some sort of structure, so I've come up with one. Rather than making a list of specific things to do (or avoid doing), I'm going to use a few questions to help me make daily choices. I offer them for you to consider using, too:

1. Is what I'm doing either necessary or enjoyable?

2. Could I approach it in a way that would render it either unnecessary or more enjoyable?

3. Is engaging in this activity the best expression of my authentic self?

The last question is especially significant. Are you being the best version of who you truly are, not who you're "supposed" to be, not who other people perceive you to be, not who you used to be some time in the past? Of course, this requires defining who you are now. That can be a fairly daunting, but worthwhile, task that will take some time (probably more than you might think).

And how does all this apply to "thoughtful consumers?" First of all, in what ways does that phrase describe you? Does it mean avoiding certain products or manufacturers because they don't appeal to your own authentic sense of what's "right?" Does it mean using public transportation or a bicycle? Does it mean living in a commune? (Shades of the sixties!) Or does it mean simply avoiding buying things that you and your family don't really need so that you don't live surrounded by clutter? However you define it, that's a reflection of your authentic self and your daily choices can be guided by that knowledge.

Guided, not propelled down some inflexible path to some unimpeachable truth. Many consumer choices are complex and confusing; some options are unaffordable or impractical. Also, situations and levels of awareness change over time and the choices you make today may not be the choices you make tomorrow. The key word in the label, "thoughtful consumer," is "thoughtful."

There's one other thing I'm going to remind myself about every day (if only I remember!) that I hope you'll remember, too: it's not necessary to be perfect; it's only necessary to do the best you can do.

If you're reading this on December 31st, you don't have to wait until tomorrow to start becoming the best version of your authentic self. Happy New Year, but happy new day, too.

(c) 2009 Cynthia Friedlob

Image Credit : (c) 2009 Billy Alexander stock.xchng

Sunday, December 20, 2009

Discardia: A Holiday for Unclutterers


Monday, the 21st, marks the return of Discardia, one of my favorite holidays. I first learned about Discardia two years ago from a post on Jeri Dansky's popular blog; the full story (which is definitely worth reading) is at the website of Dinah Sanders, who came up with the amusing idea for this clever holiday in 2002.

Although it's celebrated throughout the year (between the solstices and equinoxes and their following new moons), the celebration nearest to Christmas is particularly worth noting. I've posted about the spirit of the Discardia in the past, but the basic principle is that it's a time of letting go of unnecessary things, "things that no longer add value to your life." That requires a significant change in the way we think about our possessions. What better time to reexamine the value of possessions than during a holiday season in which the focus too often is on mindlessly giving stuff to other people who probably really don't need it?

I love giving thoughtful presents so I'm not advocating abandoning the practice. I'm just very fond of the idea of using this time to let go of lots of my excess stuff, too. Also, the end of my year-long, 365 Item Toss Uncluttering Challenge is looming, so I've used Discardia to help me make sure I met my goal -- and I have. I've even exceeded it: 486 items have been donated, recycled, re-gifted or sold in the past year! You can get more details about the challenge here on the original blog post (updates are in the comments).

If you celebrate Discardia, you'll find that what you're really doing is giving yourself a gift: freedom from too much stuff!

(c) 2009 Cynthia Friedlob

Friday, December 18, 2009

The Movie Santa Doesn't Want You To See!

Christmas is a tricky time for unclutterers. It makes us painfully aware that we're swimming upstream as far as the general society is concerned, although the tanked economy currently is making that swim quite a bit easier. But even the most confirmed unclutterer is not necessarily a grinch. Except for the ascetics among us, we'd all agree that there's nothing inherently wrong with stuff; the primary issue is the quantity of stuff that so many of us have. True, most of us who advocate living with fewer rather than more possessions would prefer to keep the tangible holiday gifts to a minimum, but that doesn't mean we don't have the spirit of the season. And yet, how does one keep the "correct" balance during a time that's so focused on giving -- or, more accurately, buying?

Bill Talen, aka "Reverend Billy," offers one answer in What Would Jesus Buy? Produced in 2007 by Morgan Spurlock of Supersize Me fame, this documentary film tackles the commercialization of Christmas but has a larger focus on the general excesses of consumerism, too. Talen, a genuinely concerned consumer, is also a comedic performance artist who resembles a younger Jerry Lee Lewis. He travels the nation as a preacher from the Church of Stop Shopping. The Reverend warns of the coming Shopocalypse: "the end of mankind from consumerism, overconsumption and the fires of eternal debt." He exorcises demons at the corporate headquarters of that well-known small business crusher, Wal-Mart. He and the Church of Stop Shopping Gospel Choir put on a rousing good show everywhere from small churches to the Mall of America (surely a place of worship for shoppers), but the message is legitimate: buy less and give more; buy locally; reduce, reuse, recycle. And buy with awareness. Who made the product? Where? At what cost to the environment? Under what labor conditions?

All of these issues are important, even urgent, but sometimes it's easy to get caught up in the seriousness of our concerns and lose the joy of the season and the fun of giving. Sometimes the message has a greater impact when the messenger makes us think and laugh, as Reverend Billy does.

If you live near Greenfield, Massachusetts, you can see the show at the Christmas Revival on December 19th. You can see the Reverend Billy's recent interview on CNN here.

Does the Reverend speak to you?

(c) 2009 Cynthia Friedlob



Tuesday, December 08, 2009

Manhattan's Smallest Home


Recently I've noticed quite a few print and on-line articles about small homes. I can only hope that this reflects our society's increasing comfort level with decreasing living space. But this article in the New York Post features the smallest home I've seen that has truly captured my imagination. In fact, had I known it was on the market, I could have been greatly tempted by the opportunity to buy it, even though it's on the opposite coast in Manhattan. Have you ever heard of a place in the city that cost only $150,000? A parking space, maybe, or a broom closet. Ah, well, it turns out that "broom closet" pretty aptly describes it.

On 110th, between Broadway and Amsterdam, sits a pre-war, sixteen-floor co-op building, with a doorman. On the top floor, there is a very tiny room that used to be one of several maids' quarters back during the building's previous configuration. At ten feet wide and less than fifteen feet long, this miniscule studio has space for a bed, a kitchen with mini-fridge and hotplate. There's also a three-foot by nine-foot bathroom (obviously no tub, just a shower, sink and toilet).

The reason this little broom closet might have been such a fabulous buy for an out-of-towner is that it could be used like a hotel room and make a bi-coastal (okay, fantasy) life possible. But what would it be like to live there?

Owners Zaarath and Christopher Prokop think it's great. They even share it with their two cats. Granted they use local dry-cleaning establishments as closets and never cook a meal at home, and I'm certain they keep all of their work-related paraphernalia in their offices, but it's still a stretch for me to imagine squeezing the complete lives of two adults into such a restricted space.

Day after day after day.

Even in the winter when it's freezing outside.

Or during a bout of the flu.

With cats!

Nope. I'll have to pass.

Could you do it? Take a look at the slide show here.

© 2009 Cynthia Friedlob

Saturday, November 21, 2009

Bleak Friday


I wrote a blog post last year about the outrageous circumstances of the tragic death of a WalMart employee on Black Friday. Jdimytai Damour was the 34-year-old temporary employee who was trampled to death as a mob of shoppers stormed the doors of a Long Island WalMart store, searching for bargains at the ironically named Green Acres Mall. In case you didn't keep track of the legal proceedings that resulted from the "incident," as it's euphemistically called, here's what WalMart agreed to do last May in order to avoid criminal prosecution:

1) implement improved "crowd management" plans at all of the 92 stores across NY state

2) set up a $400,000 fund to compensate about 11 other victims who were injured at that time

3) donate $1.5 million to social service and non-profit groups in the Long Island community

4) hire 50 local teenagers annually

Although WalMart admitted no wrong-doing as part of the terms of the settlement (which was not accepted by Charles Ogera, the victim's father), this may seem a rather paltry amount for the retail giant to fork over for what many would consider gross negligence. However, I was surprised to learn that, had the case gone to court, the maximum penalty that could have been imposed on the corporation for a felony was $10,000 -- about what WalMart earns in fifteen minutes on an average day. [Correction: The original proposed fine of $7,000 is what WalMart earns in about 18 seconds, according to the LA Times. That makes more sense.]

And yet, as much as the store may have appeared at fault in the eyes of the public, if not the eyes of the law, Bruce Watson, writing at Daily Finance, commented on the power of consumer greed that contributed to the crowd's behavior that day: "...it is worth noting that the store's customers argued with the police and employees who asked them to leave after the trampling. All told, the event suggests a deep consumerist soul-rot that is alarming."

Although economic conditions will probably slow down spending a bit this year, I wonder if we'll ever get to the root of the problem, the "soul-rot" that forces so many people to buy so much unnecessary stuff. Of course, anyone can make the choice not to participate in the shopping madness. I've written about Buy Nothing Day in the past, too; it falls on the same day as Black Friday. Maybe it will pick up a few more adherents this year. I hope so. Whatever happens, I just don't want to have to write another Angry Consumer blog post on November 27th.


(c) 2009 Cynthia Friedlob

Friday, November 13, 2009

Living Small, Paying Rent

It's no surprise that many people are rethinking the wisdom of buying a house. Property values are always supposed to go up, but the last few years have proven that assumption wrong. I don't know why anyone needed proof again; housing prices have dipped precipitously in the past. But, we seem to have a collective short memory when it comes to the unpleasant realities of the financial world.

The benefits of homeownership are familiar to most of us: you can build substantial equity if you stay in your home long enough, you can remodel to suit your tastes, you may get some helpful tax breaks, and you can enjoy feelings of stability and being a part of your community. On the other hand, you're responsible for all the maintenance bills, you can't just pick up and move if you feel like it with thirty days notice, and if your personal financial situation alters dramatically for the worse, you could end up losing your home to foreclosure, a truly unpleasant reality for many people right now.

I was always a believer in the flexibility of renting, so becoming a townhouse owner about ten years ago was a big step out of character. Fortunately, the Los Angeles housing market was just emerging from a slump, so prices were favorable for buyers. Also fortunate is the fact that the property has appreciated enough so that even in the current horrendous marketplace, it's remained a solid investment. Best of all, it's been a great place to live. But, being the kind of person who ponders, probably too often, the road not taken, I sometimes wonder how renting would have changed some of the choices that were made over the last decade.

One couple who chose to rent rather than buy are "living happily in 380 square feet" along with their nine-month-old son, Thurston, and Charlie, the dog. Kelly Breslin and Ryan Conder have furnished their miniscule apartment fashionably and functionally. Conder owns a men's clothing store; Breslin makes ceramic art, obviously not at home.

Looking at the photos in the LA Times article about them, I wondered what it would be like to live in such close quarters. My answer: not a joyful experience (okay, I phrased it more emphatically than that).

Could you do it?

(c) 2009 Cynthia Friedlob
Photo credit: Mark Manalaysay


Thursday, October 15, 2009

Blog Action Day: Climate Change

The challenge facing a call to action to deal with climate change is that the issue is not an obvious problem on a daily basis. We might notice an unseasonal heat wave, or be inconvenienced by a drought that restricts our water usage; we might even have an intellectual awareness that the issue is a serious one, but most average consumers in our country don't really suffer as a result of it -- not yet.

The majority of people probably don't even see much of a connection between consumerism and climate change, but it exists. Every product that we consume requires not only the ingredients or components of the product itself, but also a manufacturing and distribution process for those components and the final product, all which have some sort of environmental impact. Often there's also an environmental effect during or immediately after the consumption of the product.

Probably the most obvious example that contributes to the climate change problem: a car. When we buy a car, we're not just buying transportation; we're buying the various metals, glass, fiberglass, rubber, etc. that were used to build the car, as well as the manufacturing process itself. Then we need fossil fuels to run the car. Fuel requires not only raw materials (which are extracted in an environmentally unfriendly way), but also plants to process them (also not environmentally friendly). When fuel is burned in the car (and in the giant tanker trucks used to deliver the fuel to our gas stations), the waste product contributes to pollution. The Environmental Defense Fund states, "U.S. autos emit more than 333 million tons of carbon dioxide each year, more than one-fifth of the nation's total carbon dioxide emissions. Any serious effort to fight global warming must include cutting auto emissions." (Click here for a detailed analysis on the EDF site about how cars contribute to global warming.)

Everything that we consume has some kind of environmental consequences, so limiting our consumption seems to be a simple way to lessen our negative impact (our carbon footprint) on the environment. And because we are such a wealthy society, our impact is substantial. Global Issues reported that "using the latest figures available, in 2005, the wealthiest 20% of the world accounted for 76.6% of total private consumption. The poorest fifth just 1.5%" (See Material World: A Global Family Portrait, one of my favorite books, for some startling images that show the differences between us and consumers in other cultures.)

We may not have a lot of time to make changes in our patterns of consumption in order to halt and perhaps reverse the climate change trend. A recent British study predicts that the polar ice caps will be gone in twenty years. "Remove the Arctic ice cap and we are left with a very different and much warmer world. . . Loss of sea ice cover will 'set in motion powerful climate feedbacks which will have an impact far beyond the Arctic itself' . . . This could lead to flooding affecting one quarter of the world's population, substantial increases in greenhouse gas emission from massive carbon pools and extreme global weather changes."

Well, that would get our attention, but let's not wait that long. We can get involved right now by supporting these or many other fine organizations that are making efforts to deal with climate change:

The Nature Conservancy

Greenpeace

Oxfam

There are also opportunities for political involvement here:

350.org (sponsors of the International Day of Climate Action, October 24th)

TckTckTck (a cooperative umbrella organization working for an international agreement to address this issue at the UN Climate Change Conference in Copenhagen, December 7-18, 2009. You can read more about the UN's effort to make this deal happen.)

And you can check out the other 7900+ blogs from all over the world that are participating in Blog Action Day. [Update at 4:00 p.m. Pacific Time: over 10,000 bloggers are participating and the event was kicked off by a topical post from UK Prime Minister Gordon Brown.]

I know, it seems a little overwhelming. I've written in the past about "shopper's compassion fatigue," that oppressive feeling of the weight of the world on our shoulders that we can get when trying to make the "right" decision about what to buy, or whether to buy at all. But as long as we're all traveling together on this small planet, it seems like a good idea to do what we can to keep that planet healthy enough to take care of us. And nobody ever said that being a thoughtful consumer was easy.

© 2009 Cynthia Friedlob

Thursday, October 08, 2009

Alternative Housing: Intentional Communities

[There was a Feedburner technical glitch affecting the distribution of my last post on September 25th, "Going Wrong Going Green, Part 2," and I was never able to get the feed to update. If you subscribe to this blog by RSS Feed, you probably didn't receive the post, so you may want to take a moment to read it at your convenience.]

I’ve talked in the past about alternative types of housing, but the alternatives have always referred to structural and environmental issues. What about other types of alternative housing? What about housing that encourages people to live in a more communal spirit?

Throughout human history, groups of people with common bonds have lived together in a community, either a shared physical location or, in the case of nomadic tribes, a shared pattern of roaming. When civilization moved beyond the tribal stage, religious beliefs were the common bonds that held together villages and most small towns. When we moved into the era of multiple types of groups living in larger urban areas, ethnic bonds usually prevailed. Sometimes this offered the comfort and familiarity of a community; sometimes it resulted in impoverished ghettos. Larger societies also have class or caste systems that create communities. Some are blatant, like those in India or England; some are more subtle, like Japan or Israel. Here in “the land of the free, home of the brave,” we have a massive mix of groups, many still astonishingly segregated, and a class system in which higher echelons can be cracked, to a substantial degree, with enough financial success.

So where do modern “intentional communities” fit in? There are still religious and cultural forms like ashrams and kibbutzes, and, in the U.S., communities like the Amish, or Native Americans who live on tribal lands. But there are also other types of intentional communities, communes and cohousing, which are based on shared philosophies or on simple economic need.

In addition to shared philosophy, communes have a shared economy, i.e., the communal structure generates at least some income for the members. Aging Boomers who were politically active liberals probably remember The Farm, Steven Gaskin’s “noble experiment” and a classic commune. An English professor at San Francisco State, Gaskin witnessed the explosion, then implosion, of the Haight-Ashbury district during the late 1960s. His response was to buy land in Tennessee and, along with a few hundred followers, set up an intentional community that was held together by the philosophical beliefs of anti-materialism, vegetarianism and self-sufficiency. The Farm still exists, in spite of bumps along the way, and now includes charitable service as part of its philosophy.

According to the CoHousing.org website, "The cohousing idea originated in Denmark, and was promoted in the U.S. by architects Kathryn McCamant and Charles Durrett in the early 1980s. . . [Cohousing brings] together the value of private homes with the benefits of more sustainable living. . . The common house is the social center of a community, with a large dining room and kitchen, lounge, recreational facilities, children’s spaces, and frequently a guest room, workshop and laundry room. Communities usually serve optional group meals in the common house at least two or three times a week."
Click here for the six defining characteristics of cohousing. One is that the cohousing community is not a source of income for its members, making this arrangement distinct from a commune.
Check out EcoVillage in Ithaca, New York; Milagro Co-housing in Tucson, Arizona; and Prairie Onion Cohousing, right in the city of Chicago for examples of cohousing.

Finances may be pushing a lot of people who have never considered it before into alternative living arrangements. Multi-generational families are sharing homes again after the latest stock market and housing meltdowns. Finances are also often an issue for older people who are alone and either have limited resources or want to spend their later years in a more collegial setting than what passes for "neighborhood" in many larger cities. Boomers Go Back to the Commune in Retirement, an informative article from Bankrate.com, discusses this trend. It's particularly significant for older women, who usually outlive their husbands. A Smart Money magazine article states, "The 2006 Census found that 7.4 million women aged 65 and older live alone, compared with 2.7 million men. . . Even scarier: In 2005, the Census found that 12% of women age 65 and older were living in poverty, a sizable chunk more than the 7% of men in the same group."

But I liked the story of one resourceful Asheville, NC, woman: "[I]nstead of joining an existing [intentional] community, the self-described maverick set up her own, buying two houses in a three-house enclave. Now, she lives in one house, rents her second property to two other single women, and has a friend living next door. 'It's like being married to four different people,' says Kilkenny, who helped organize the 'Women Living in Community' conference in Asheville in July. 'You drive into your driveway and there's someone there. It's huge for me. I can walk out on my porch and say 'Morning, Bobbie, want a cup of coffee?' There's camaraderie.'"

We can talk about all kinds of ways to live more lightly on the Earth, we can debate all kinds of strategies to get through difficult financial times, and we can lament the lack of community that so many of us feel. The simplest solutions for most of us are to live in smaller spaces, keep our living costs affordable and get to know our neighbors. I've got the first two solutions covered, but I just met my "new" next door neighbor last week. She's lived in her townhouse for a little over a year. What can I say? LA's a tough town.

Find more information at:

© 2009 Cynthia Friedlob
Image: Jackie at StockVault.net

Friday, September 25, 2009

Going Wrong Going Green, Part 2

Synchronicity, according to Dictionary.com, is "a coincidence of events that seem to be meaningfully related." After my previous post, I haven't been searching for more examples of the complexity of the decision-making process when you want to be a thoughtful consumer, but the LA Times had two articles today that relate to the topic. Synchronicity? Why not?

First, fabric. Let's consider the fact that many consumers who think of themselves as concerned and aware disdain anything other than "natural" fabrics like cotton, yet "Hard Truths about Uzbek Cotton," an opinion piece written by Tom Harkin (D-Iowa), details the plight of children forced to pick cotton in Uzbekistan, the world's third largest exporter of cotton -- cotton that ends up in our marketplace.

"Unlike most instances of forced child labor in agriculture, this mass mobilization is not driven by exploitative plantation owners or desperate families but by the government. . . Consumers and companies in the West prop up this monstrous system by unwittingly purchasing cotton harvested by forced child labor. Supply chain analysts have determined that most Uzbek cotton is sold to countries in South Asia and Eastern Europe. From there, the cotton is processed and turned into garments sold in retail stores in the United States, Canada and Western Europe."

Is child slave labor cotton any more acceptable than blood diamonds? No.

And don't think that buying "organic cotton" necessarily solves the problem. Erik Cussack's "Organic Cotton" blog has interesting posts about fake organic cotton that's being sold as the real thing and about genetically-modified organic cotton from India. Also, if organic cotton fabric is dyed with toxic chemicals, which does happen, that defeats its purpose. There's also a cost factor if you're purchasing most legitimate organic cotton goods; not everyone can afford a $35 T-shirt.

The next issue may sound amusing, but it really isn't: toilet paper. Reporter David A. Fahrenthold wrote, "Environmentalists Target Plush Toilet Paper," in which he explains that "plush U.S. toilet paper is usually made by chopping down and grinding up trees that were decades or even a century old. Environmentalists want Americans, like Europeans, to wipe with tissue made from recycled paper goods."

Although toilet paper and facial tissues account for only 5% of the products made from "the forest goods industry," do we really want to cut down a single old growth tree so that we can have three-ply toilet paper? No.

And finally, before I put to rest, at least for awhile, the problems inherent in going green, I want to close with some information I just happened to come across recently having to do with ethanol, which has been touted as as a biofuel alternative to gasoline. In 2008, the U.S. and Brazil produced 89% of the supply of ethanol fuel; Brazil has been nicknamed "the Saudi Arabia of biofuels."

From Wikipedia: "Because it is easy to manufacture and process and can be made from very common crops such as sugar cane, potato, manioc and corn, in several countries ethanol fuel is increasingly being blended as gasohol or used as an oxygenate in gasoline. Bioethanol, unlike petroleum, is a renewable resource that can be produced from agricultural feedstocks."

This makes it an appealing commodity to environmentalists. But, it turns out that, in addition to potential ecological problems affecting water quality (see the NY Times) and the contamination of grain fed to livestock (see Minnesota Public Radio), once again the human cost must be considered.

According to an LA Times article by Patrick J. McDonnell from June, 2008, "[m]ore than 300,000 farmworkers are seasonal [sugar] cane cutters in Brazil, the government says. By most accounts, their work and living conditions range from basic to deplorable to outright servitude. . . In its annual report, Amnesty International last month highlighted the plight of Brazil's biofuel workers, more than 1,000 of whom were rescued in June 2007 after allegedly being held in slave-like conditions at a plantation owned by a major ethanol producer. . . Although slavery cases tend to grab headlines, advocates say laborers typically face more quotidian abuse -- low pay, excessive work hours, inadequate safety gear, an absence of sanitary and health services, and exposure to pesticides and other toxic chemicals."

So, this is what it takes to produce one type of alternative fuel? Is that okay with everyone? No.

Unfortunately, I could list many more situations that most consumers may not be aware of, including some that I've covered in previous posts (see, for example, Fair Trade Jewelry). Clearly it's not easy to understand the complex issues surrounding every single thing we buy, to make the right decision, to do the right thing. But accepting that fact may at least help us make some decisions that we know are right:

I know for certain that I can live without that third ply.

© 2009 Cynthia Friedlob

Photo credit: FreeDigitalPhotos.net